once again i'm feeling chipper. hopefully this monday doesn't end up like last monday did. but things are steadily improving, albeit slowly.
i got some awesome love from my frisbee folks. been meaning to catch up with them, and i finally got the nudge to do it. what a great group of peeps. chalu painj.
finally forced myself to start the rosetta stone lessons. doing farsi. only made it through two lessons, and i think i'm going to have to re-start it and take notes this time. i was a bit lost at the end there. that, and apparently there's an issue somewhere in the compulator. the speech recognition stuff isn't working. army internet stuff doesn't like firefox, apparently. or maybe just my computer. hopefully i'll get it going, but at least i'm doing something.
so i'm in a rather chipper mood. i probably shouldn't be, but hopefully i can keep it up. of course, i'm reading a lot of solemn posts and less solemn facebookery from friends on "patriot day." but my september 11th thoughts have been buoyed by
this little discovery.
On the morning of 11th September 2001, the world discovered the unstoppable chain of events both you and al-Qaeda had put in place. Why was this operation carried out? What has the 11th September brought to the world except mass killings, occupations, destruction, hatred of Muslims, humiliation of Islam, and a tighter grip on the lives of ordinary Muslims by the authoritarian regimes that control Arab and Muslim states? I warned you then, in summer 2000, of how your actions would bring US forces into the Middle East and into Afghanistan, leading to mass unrest and loss of life. You believed I was wrong. Time has proved me right. Your actions have harmed millions of innocent Muslims and non-Muslims alike. How is this Islam or jihad? For how much longer will al-Qaeda continue to bring shame on Islam, disrupt ordinary Muslims' lives, and be the cause of global unrest?
damn, son, you got served! so who wrote that? how about "
Noman Benotman, a former commander in the Libyan Islamic Fighting Group (LIFG) and a former associate of Osama bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahiri."
game changer? probably not. but it's exactly the kind of thing that needs to happen. islam (speaking VERY broadly) is in a crisis of faith. moderate islam has yet to assert itself and repudiate the, shall we say, unsavory parts of the koran. it has yet to define what it is about the faith that offers something better in life. Of course, it is a cultural adhesive in regions steeped in history, but eventually religion has to offer a better life, not just a better afterlife. God would see through Pascal's wager.
of course, i don't believe in god. i'm just saying, God, if he existed, and were, you know... GOD, would be able to detect insincerity. i would also think he would look beyond faith itself and into your soul to know if you were, at heart, a decent human being.*
the koran, from what i've read, is a much less, erm, inspiring manuscript, than the other two judeo-christian texts (and i thought being a lutheran was rough!). but they all have their faults. faults which must either result in severe cognitive dissonance in believers, or severe ignorance. sure, religions have done a good job co-opting cultural traditions to provide deeper meaning behind such odd behaviors as hanging figurines on a pine tree near the winter solstice and hiding colored eggs. but in order to really thrive, religion has to offer something more, a reason for people to believe, a promise for the future. islam doesn't seem to me to offer much; over the past 9 years things have pretty much gone down the shitter.
but there are signs of hope. mr. benotman's words have really cheered me up. i hate to believe that it's true, but we won't walk away from afghanistan with anything to be proud of unless we win the narrative, and we don't control the narrative. we're outsiders, imposers. no matter how genuine we are and no matter who marginally competent we manage to be, we can not afford to stay in iraq or afghanistan forever. we will not have the luxury of even attempting to impose our will.
what follows in our wake will be determined by the collective will of the people. some areas will always be hostile to us, to our values, and they will continue to live in the shadows. whether they stay in the shadows, or whether they, or those they inspire, have the wherewithal to wantonly kill innocent, free people abroad, will be determined by those just outside of the shadows, those poor, struggling people of southwest and central asia who have been mired in poverty for far too long by wars and corrupt governments.
what will they do? will they turn to a faith that offers them more than the cold calculus of revenge and the sanctity of blood? will they turn to a faith that binds them to a code of decency and to a love of life and community? the future of islam will only be determined by its adherents. many blessings upon your house, mr. benotman. may many more like you come forward to reclaim your faith, for the sake of us all.
method of destruction - get up and dance
* in fact: i do think that. that's why i'm not sweating the wager. if i'm wrong, and god does exist, then he will surely judge me on the merits. if he judges me on whether i was sufficiently supplicant, then he's no god worth supplicating to.